Belzuz Advogados, S.L.P. has been confronted on several occasions with situations involving insurance contracts, particularly in the life sector, which have come to court due to a clear disagreement between the parties regarding the annulment of the contract due to inaccurate statements made when the contract was signed.
The question that arises is whether an insurer who declares a claim based solely on the omission and inaccuracy of information, even if it can be proved in court, provided by the insured at the time of the initial declaration of risk, is acting under the law.
And the answer, in line with what has been understood, namely by the Supreme Court of Justice, is that it is not enough to prove that the insurer would not have concluded the insurance contract or, at the very least, would have subjected it to an increase in the respective premium. The insurer will have to go further and prove the essentiality of the error.
It is clear that article 25 of the Insurance Contract Law (LCS) provides for the possibility of annulling the life insurance contract but, with regard to the application of the regime provided for therein, according to which the provision of inaccurate statements or omission of relevant clinical circumstances allows the insurer to annul the insurance contract, it has been the uniform understanding of the STJ case law that two requirements must be met, the burden of proof of which lies solely with the insurer: (i) the causality between the intent and the error; and (ii) the essentiality of the error to the conclusion of the contract.
The insurance contract is taken out to cover a certain risk and the premium is calculated based on this risk. This is why the declaration of risk is so important, as it will enable the insurer to calculate the premium and, as a result, accept or reject the insurance proposal.
The declaration of risk is therefore a pre-contractual duty incumbent on the policyholder/insured to be settled and is supported by articles 24 to 26 of the LCS, from which it follows that the facts and circumstances of which the insurer is aware, and which must be taken into consideration for the assessment of the risk must be declared accurately and completely.
However, in the case of a specific case, if the insured person has proven that he or she has failed to comply with this pre-contractual duty, namely because he or she knowingly omitted relevant information, the application of the annulment regime provided for in article 25 of the LCS can no longer be invoked, since the essential nature of the error still has to be proven.
And it is this proof that, in our view, is extremely difficult to achieve. For the error to be relevant, it must play a decisive role in determining the declarant’s (insurer’s) will, so that if he had known about it, he would not have wanted to conclude the deal.
It is not enough for the insurer to claim that if it had known of the insured’s true state of health, it would not have taken out the contract or would have subjected him to an increase in the premium. The insurer will have to prove that the premium increase would have been so high that it would not have been accepted by the insured and therefore the contract would not have been concluded. And here, yes, in the view of the prevailing case law, the essentiality of the error will be proven and it will be possible to annul the contract, under the terms of article 25 of the LCS.
In this scenario – inaccurate or omitted statements – it is therefore not enough for the insurer to prove that it would not have concluded the contract in any case, since it will have to prove that the risk associated with the omitted information does not fall within the scope of its coverage, which is not compatible with the well-known fact that insurers cover the most different and varied risks. It is therefore necessary to go further by proving that the premium was significantly increased, and that the insured did not accept it. Only in this way will the essentiality of the error be proven.
In view of the consistent interpretation of Article 25 of the LCS, it is therefore necessary for insurers to recalculate the risk, and the premium based on the policyholder’s/insured’s declarations, considering the information omitted about the insured’s state of health, and calculating the increase in risk with certainty.
There are no perfect solutions, but in view of the legal requirement, the more information the insurer has when taking out the policy, the better it can defend itself against these situations, since detailed and thorough knowledge of the insured person’s true condition makes it possible, whenever a claim is reported, to detect foreseen exclusion situations, of which pre-existing conditions stand out.
Filling in detailed medical questionnaires identifying the pathologies and circumstances to be aware of, also recording them on sound recordings, and certifying them through clinical documentation with specific (and not generic) information, as well as requesting observation and medical examinations when there are doubts when weighing up the risk, not least because at this point the policyholder is willing to collaborate, are preventive measures that should not be overlooked.
Our insurance lawyers in Portugal have a large experience providing legal advice from the management of the claims process to the end of the legal proceedings.