De Facto Relationships and Portuguese Nationality: When Is Judicial Recognition Required?

Can a person acquire Portuguese nationality through a de facto relationship?

Yes.

Under Article 3(3) of the Portuguese Nationality Law, a foreign national who, on the date of the declaration, has lived in a de facto relationship with a Portuguese citizen for more than three years may acquire Portuguese nationality after obtaining a judicial recognition decision from the court with jurisdiction.

The acquisition of nationality is not automatic. The applicant must:

  1. live in a de facto relationship with a Portuguese citizen;
  2. demonstrate that the relationship has existed for more than three years;
  3. obtain a court decision recognizing the relationship and its duration;
  4. declare the intention to acquire Portuguese nationality;
  5. submit the nationality application together with the documents required by law;
  6. not be subject to any of the statutory grounds that prevent the acquisition of nationality.

Judicial recognition of the relationship and the nationality proceeding are therefore two separate proceedings.

Why is a court decision required?

Marriage is subject to civil registration. Its existence and duration can be established through the corresponding civil registry certificate.

A de facto relationship, by contrast, is not entered in the Civil Registry and does not depend on the execution of a deed, contract, or other constitutive act. It is a legal relationship based on the factual reality of the couple’s shared life.

For this reason, a simple declaration by the partners is not sufficient for nationality purposes. The court must recognize:

  1. the existence of a shared life under conditions comparable to those of married spouses;
  2. the stability, continuity, and exclusivity of the relationship;
  3. the existence of a shared life plan;
  4. the continuation of the relationship for more than three years.

The judgment must identify the date from which the de facto relationship is deemed to have been established. A general statement that the relationship exists is not sufficient.

The judicial action and the nationality proceeding are separate proceedings

The purpose of the judicial action is to obtain recognition of the de facto relationship. The nationality application is subsequently reviewed by the Civil Registry authorities.

Article 14 of the Portuguese Nationality Regulation requires the proceeding to include, among other documents:

  1. the declaration of intent to acquire Portuguese nationality;
  2. a certified copy of the court decision;
  3. the Portuguese citizen’s birth certificate, unless its submission is waived;
  4. a declaration by the Portuguese citizen, issued less than three months previously, confirming that the de facto relationship is ongoing.

The judgment does not, by itself, grant nationality. It merely establishes one of the requirements for its subsequent acquisition.

How does the recognition proceeding work?

The declaratory action must be filed against the Portuguese State, represented by the Public Prosecutor’s Office.

The partners must allege the facts characterizing their shared life and identify the date from which they began living under conditions comparable to those of married spouses.

The Lisbon Court of Appeals has held that the Portuguese State has standing to participate in these proceedings, given their purpose of supporting an application for nationality and the need to ensure due process and an opportunity to be heard. It has also recognized that the partners have a legitimate procedural interest in obtaining the judgment required to submit the nationality application.

What facts and documents should be submitted?

Living at the same address, when considered on its own, does not necessarily establish the existence of a de facto relationship. The parties must demonstrate the existence of a genuine shared life.

Relevant facts may include:

  1. a shared habitual residence;
  2. joint organization of domestic life;
  3. the sharing of expenses and responsibilities;
  4. mutual personal and financial support;
  5. presenting themselves publicly and socially as a couple;
  6. having children together;
  7. jointly purchasing or leasing a home;
  8. naming the partner under insurance policies or employment benefits;
  9. the continuation of the relationship for more than three years.

Evidence may include:

  1. residence records;
  2. lease agreements;
  3. documents relating to the purchase of a home;
  4. water, electricity, and telecommunications bills;
  5. bank statements and money transfers;
  6. tax returns;
  7. insurance policies;
  8. medical or school records;
  9. birth certificates of the couple’s children;
  10. photographs, travel records, and correspondence;
  11. witness testimony.

No single item of evidence is necessarily decisive when considered in isolation. The evidence should be consistent and must make it possible to reconstruct the development of the couple’s shared life.

Is a declaration issued by the local parish council sufficient?

No.

A declaration issued by a Portuguese local parish council, known as a Junta de Freguesia, may constitute evidence of the couple’s shared residence or the existence of the relationship. However, it does not replace the court decision required for the acquisition of nationality.

The same applies to private declarations, contracts, tax documents, and joint bank accounts. These may be used to establish the de facto relationship in court, but they do not eliminate the need for a judgment.

What if the de facto relationship was recognized abroad?

In such cases, it is essential to distinguish among three situations:

  1. the existence of an actual foreign court decision;
  2. the existence of an administrative or notarial act that has a decision-making function;
  3. the existence of a merely declaratory deed based on statements made by the parties themselves.

As a general rule, a foreign decision concerning private rights must be reviewed and recognized before it can take effect in Portugal, under Articles 978 et seq. of the Portuguese Code of Civil Procedure. The Portuguese system is primarily based on a formal review through which the court examines the legal regularity of the foreign decision without conducting a full retrial on the merits.

Article 980 of the Portuguese Code of Civil Procedure requires, in particular:

  1. the authenticity and intelligibility of the decision;
  2. the finality of the decision in the country of origin;
  3. the international jurisdiction of the foreign court;
  4. the absence of pending proceedings or an incompatible final judgment in Portugal;
  5. proper service of process and compliance with the principles of due process and equality of the parties;
  6. compatibility of the outcome with Portuguese international public policy.

A foreign decision recognizing a stable union is not incompatible with Portuguese international public policy merely because the foreign legal system applies different requirements. This may be the case with the cohabitation requirement, which does not exist in Brazil but is essential in Portugal.

The recognition proceeding does not require the foreign and Portuguese legal institutions to be absolutely identical. The applicable limit is whether the outcome is manifestly incompatible with the fundamental principles of the Portuguese legal system.

Is recognition of a foreign judgment sufficient to acquire Portuguese nationality?

Not necessarily.

Recognition of a foreign judgment gives the judgment legal effect in Portugal, but it does not mean that the Portuguese court has directly examined the facts and requirements set forth in Article 3(3) of the Portuguese Nationality Law.

In recognition proceedings, the court primarily conducts a formal review. As a rule, it does not retry the relationship or independently determine whether the union satisfies all the requirements for the acquisition of Portuguese nationality.

For this reason, Portuguese courts have held that the recognition of a foreign judgment declaring the existence of a stable union does not automatically replace the recognition action specifically required under the Portuguese Nationality Law.

The recognized foreign decision may produce other effects in Portugal and may constitute particularly relevant evidence. However, it does not necessarily amount to the judicial recognition required for nationality purposes.

Can a Brazilian stable union deed be recognized in Portugal?

As a rule, no, when the deed merely records statements made by the parties themselves.

Portuguese Supreme Court Precedent-Setting Judgment No. 10/2022 established that a Brazilian public deed declaring the existence of a stable union does not constitute a decision having the effect of a final judgment. It is therefore not eligible for review and recognition under Articles 978 et seq. of the Portuguese Code of Civil Procedure.

The distinction lies in the nature of the notary’s involvement. In a merely declaratory deed, the notary certifies that the parties made certain statements, but does not independently assess the facts or issue a binding decision regarding the existence of the relationship.

The deed may nevertheless be submitted as evidence in the Portuguese recognition action. Its evidentiary weight must be assessed together with the remaining documents and witness testimony.

This differs from the approach taken with certain foreign acts in which a notarial or administrative authority performs a constitutive or decision-making role. Brazilian deeds of consensual divorce may, in certain circumstances, fall into this category. In those cases, the relevant authority does not merely record the parties’ statements. It verifies compliance with the legal requirements and directly changes the parties’ civil status.

The Lisbon Court of Appeals has also held that a declaratory stable union deed may be admitted as evidence, but does not replace the Portuguese action filed against the Portuguese State, in which the relevant facts must be established and the right to be heard must be fully ensured.

Common mistakes

The most common mistakes include:

  1. submitting a nationality application without first obtaining a court decision;
  2. assuming that a declaration issued by the local parish council is sufficient;
  3. assuming that a Brazilian stable union deed can be recognized in the same way as a court judgment;
  4. confusing the recognition of a foreign decision with the specific judicial action required for nationality purposes;
  5. assuming that recognition of a foreign judgment always eliminates the need for a Portuguese action;
  6. limiting the evidence to proof of a shared address;
  7. failing to request recognition of a specific starting date for the relationship;
  8. omitting periods during which the partners lived in different countries;
  9. failing to demonstrate that the relationship is still ongoing;
  10. submitting foreign documents without an apostille, legalization, or appropriate translation;
  11. filing the action before a court that lacks subject-matter jurisdiction;
  12. failing to coordinate the judicial strategy with the requirements of the subsequent nationality proceeding.

Conclusion

A foreign national who has lived in a de facto relationship with a Portuguese citizen for more than three years may acquire Portuguese nationality. However, the applicant must first obtain a court decision recognizing the existence and duration of the relationship.

When the relationship has been recognized abroad, the analysis becomes more complex. Recognition of a foreign judgment allows that judgment to take effect in Portugal, but it does not necessarily replace the recognition action required for the acquisition of Portuguese nationality.

The court hearing the foreign judgment recognition proceeding primarily reviews the legal regularity of that judgment. In contrast, the court with jurisdiction to recognize the de facto relationship must examine the facts establishing the relationship and its duration.

A Brazilian public deed declaring the existence of a stable union is also not equivalent to a court judgment. Although it may constitute important evidence, it is generally not eligible for judicial recognition and does not eliminate the need to bring a Portuguese recognition action.

The legal strategy should therefore be defined from the outset. The nature of the foreign document, the court with jurisdiction, the starting date of the relationship, the continuity of the couple’s shared life, and coordination with the subsequent nationality application must be considered together.

At Belzuz Abogados, S.L.P. – Portuguese Branch, we advise Portuguese and international clients on judicial proceedings for recognition of de facto relationships, proceedings for the review and recognition of foreign decisions, and applications for the acquisition of Portuguese nationality. We provide an integrated approach combining family law, private international law, nationality law, and civil registration law.

Request specialized legal advice

Our team of lawyers analyses your case and provides clear, strategic legal solutions tailored to your situation.

Explain your situation and receive a personalised proposal

Other publications

error: Content is protected !!